dear friends, I appreciate any suggestions or comments on the following RFE. I can find 4-5 independent letters. I hired a lawyer, but did not get any advice on how to address #2, and #3 in the recommendation letters.
1. independent reference letters
2. Show extensive independent citation of my
papers--Although it has been shown that your research
has be published in the international journals in the
field and it was show that one of your papers was one
of the “”most viewed articles’ in xxx, this
does not establish that other independent researchers
have relied upon your research. It is reasonable to
conclude that other scientist will read and review
many articles in international journals. Reading and
reviewing of you article even at high rate is not
indicative of influenced ad defined by the services.
The service has found that being published and read in
these journals is inherent to all researchers. A more
important factor in determining you influence on the
filed would be the extensive and widespread citation
of your work. A search of Google Scholar for you works
shows that most the citations are from you colleagues,
collaborators, or are self-citations. This alone does
not establish that your research has influenced the
field as a whole. Please submit evidence of the
extensive and frequent citation of the beneficiary
research. This is firm evidence that other independent
researcher have be influenced by beneficiary’s work.
Please submit the number of time and the names of the
specific independent researchers citing the
beneficiary research
3. show that I have reviewed an unusual large number
of articles for many journals--Lastly, even though it
has been shown that
you have been invited as reviewer for xxxx, this does
not shown that you have influenced the field
significantly above your peers. Reviewing other
articles is expected in the scientific community. In
fact in may be a detriment to a scientist career if
it’s not done. A more accurate way of showing that
you have influenced the field more that other sin the
field would be to show that you have reviewed a
unusually large number of articles, received
independent requests from a substantial number of
journal, or served in an editorial position for
distinguished journal. Please submit evidence that
will show this. "
Thank you very much