huntridge2018-11-08 02:37:26

https://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?t=67277

 

#7

Post by David C. Clarke » 01 Jan 2005, 05:01

Yes Panzerfaust, I understand that and the Marines in particular often fought outnumbered. The point I was trying to make is that there is a tactical difference between "Human Wave" tactics and those used by the Chinese. In a "Human Wave" tactic, well, think WWI, where everyone goes "over the top" and rushes at an objective attempting to swamp it with sheer numbers. The Chinese used small groups of men taking advantage of the terrain and coordinated them so that the groups would arrive from different directions simultaneously. The preferred tactic in Korea was to infiltrate around the UN soldier's flanks and into the rear, eliminating strong points one by one--but that's not the same as a blind rush forward, charging into the machine guns regardless of losses. 

Best Regards, 
David
武疯子2018-11-08 02:54:26
这位网友比较友好,也有一定的客观态度。但是37线攻打砥平里和第5次战役是不折不扣的人海战术
青松站2018-11-08 03:16:44
有些道理,有讨论一些二十世纪战争史的书籍,提到一战中的法德线,往往也提到"心理上的人海
武疯子2018-11-08 03:22:27
林、粟不约而同的具有一样名将必备的素质:绝不让吃过的亏白吃
青松站2018-11-08 03:22:32
记得看过的一些相关文章,往往提到以血肉之躯冲在机关枪前面的历史,当时机关枪刚面世…一一
青松站2018-11-08 03:23:31
对,有些话,多年后还是叫人动容一一
青松站2018-11-08 03:26:21
彭总有句"我苦,也能挑这个"苦战的担子"(大意),一一所以也更明白有自知之明的粟裕辞将的原因一二了一一
武疯子2018-11-08 03:27:33
所以“谁敢横刀立马,唯我彭大将军”是名不虚传的
青松站2018-11-08 03:31:38
是的:共产党部队的人材全面,从上到下,而且土气足,没有对手不佩服的,联和国军参战部队的回忆,
青松站2018-11-08 03:39:08
我九十年代中到加拿大后,曾在本地报纸上见到加国老兵的一个与志愿军战士的故事,有趣的是,提出中美G2的英历史学家,作家
武疯子2018-11-08 03:58:48
在哪儿?
青松站2018-11-08 04:06:05
我纠正一下,是位加拿大老兵,同忆当年他还个楞头青,在战场上(可查一下,是志愿军入朝不久的战役),他与中国战士面对面,他吃惊之余:
LogicalPls2018-11-08 05:12:32
当士兵明白并且同意战争的目的和意义,并愿意为此牺牲时,如果是最后的选择,为了胜利,人海战术怎么了!
吃素的狼2018-11-08 07:19:55
彭大将军内战时木有遭遇国军的“五大主力”,对火力密度和机动作战的认识和经验有限,是不能和林粟相提并论滴。
lidongmei2018-11-08 11:41:17
苏军抗德,国军抗日,才是标准的人海战术。