Giantfan2018-01-24 16:31:24

M-10 上阻挡德军突围.  这是发生在 "Colmar Pocket" 包围圈里. 

首先文章让我质疑的是文中提到的虎式坦克.  虎式坦克因产量低只配置在各重坦克营和党卫军主力师中, 所以碰到虎式坦克的机会跟这些单位的布置有关.  Colmar Pocket 德军的作战单位是第十九集团军配第 106th 装甲旅, 没有重坦克营.   

而 Audie Murphy 当时所处的真实情形是这样的

General John W. O'Daniel's 3rd U.S. Infantry Division attacked to the southeast on 22 January, aiming to cross the Ill River, bypass the city of Colmar to the north, and open a path for the tanks of the French 5th Armored Division to drive on the railway bridge supplying the Germans in the Colmar Pocket at Neuf-Brisach.

The bridge at Maison Rouge proved unable to support U.S. tanks (the bridge collapsed under the weight of a tank), and so the 30th Infantry had only minimal antitank capability (bazookas and three 57 mm anti-tank guns) when they were counter-attacked late in the afternoon by German infantry and heavy tank destroyers of the 708th Volksgrenadier Division and 280th Assault Gun Battalion. Without cover and unable to dig foxholes because of the frozen terrain, the 30th Infantry was forced to withdraw, taking heavy casualties when the withdrawal assumed the character of a rout.  The 30th Infantry reformed on the west bank of the Ill but was out of action for three days while it reorganized.

  所以虎式坦克是不可能在那里出现的

On 25 January, the U.S. 15th Infantry Regiment followed the course of the 30th Infantry and recaptured the bridge at Maison Rouge. A German counterattack, again supported by heavy tank destroyers, overran an exposed rifle company of the 15th Infantry around 08:00 but was unable to drive on the bridge because of U.S. defensive fire. Later in the day, U.S. engineers erected a bridge over the Ill north of Maison Rouge, and a battalion of the 15th Infantry supported by tanks attacked to the south, finally securing the bridgehead. Over the next two days, the 15th Infantry pushed south toward the towns of Riedwihr and Holtzwihr, entering the Riedwihr Woods. German counterattacks were common, but the U.S. troops were able to parry them with support from tanks and tank destroyers.

  没有美军装甲部队支持, 反坦克对美步兵来说是非常困难的

On 26 January, on the south edge of the Riedwihr Woods, a German force of infantry and tanks emerged from Holtzwihr to counterattack Company B of the 15th Infantry. Believing the odds hopeless, Lieutenant Audie Murphy ordered his men to withdraw into the woods.  Murphy climbed onto a burning M10 tank destroyer and engaged the Germans with the vehicle's heavy machine gun while calling for artillery fire on his own position. Unable to determine where Murphy was firing from, the German force first became confused and then was bombed by U.S. fighter-bombers that had found a hole in the clouds over the battlefield. Dismayed, the German force retreated back to Holtzwihr, pursued by Lieutenant Murphy. He was subsequently awarded the Medal of Honor. 

  所以反坦克还是那几样: 火炮和战斗轰炸机



"孤身击毁16辆德军坦克,击毙240名纳粹士兵"  不知出处在哪?

USAAF  二战前归陆军指挥, 但在二战中是独立指挥, 跟 RAF, VVS 一样的盟军空军独立兵种.