Girlsmom922022-05-09 15:54:40

My daughter and her friends signed a lease and emailed it to landlord yesterday and then got an offer for another apartment which they like the best just after that. They immediately called the landlord and want to withdraw the signed lease (I am sure the landlord haven't signed the lease yet since they ask pay 2 months security and first month starting at Aug 1 when sign but the girls haven't paid anything yet), at the phone call, the landlord agree. But then the girls emailed the landlord to confirm the phone conversation. The landlord emailed back said they won't release them until they found replacement. Is the landlord right? I think there is no contract because the landlord not signed the lease and give the girls a copy yet. Before that, the girls should have a choice since the landlord have the choice to pick other applicants. Thanks!

Girlsmom922022-05-09 15:55:29
Forgot to mention, it’s in PA
borisg2022-05-09 15:59:03
no rent or deposit paid, no key taken=no contract.
柠檬椰子汁2022-05-09 16:02:18
Lease starting 8/1 ? No problem.
柠檬椰子汁2022-05-09 16:04:40
if the landlord is a big company
Girlsmom922022-05-09 16:06:06
Thank you! That’s what I think
Girlsmom922022-05-09 16:07:39
Thank you! It’s husband and wife team
柠檬椰子汁2022-05-09 16:08:29
technically there is a contract but no performance
Ginger1232022-05-09 16:09:06
我的个人感觉,没签合同当然可以走人,这个landlord只能认栽。如果这个landlord之前要求你女儿付了
柠檬椰子汁2022-05-09 16:09:12
Then hopefully/likely they don't have a lawyer standing by
MrsKwok2022-05-09 16:12:16
我的看法是,你女儿已签了,房东只要签上他/她合同就成立了,不管还有没有
柠檬椰子汁2022-05-09 16:16:04
其实和买房子一样,签了合同没给EMD,可以走人,卖主也不会追。
Ginger1232022-05-09 16:16:24
没看清楚,你女儿这方已签了字并且email给房东了,那么就看房东愿不愿轻易放过你女儿,他们还是在试探你女儿的反应。
Girlsmom922022-05-09 16:20:30
But the landlord haven’t signed it and emailed back.
hhtt2022-05-09 16:22:00
租房改主意关系不大,就是別以后订婚了再换人?
Girlsmom922022-05-09 16:22:55
Do the landlord need to prove they signed the lease
MrsKwok2022-05-09 16:24:10
但要想玩法律,实际上是已成立的了合同…..房东追不追得到损失是另一回事了。
柠檬椰子汁2022-05-09 16:24:13
订婚换人,总比以后离婚强!
Ginger1232022-05-09 16:25:04
那么你也可以说,这是你们可以拒付走人的理由。
柠檬椰子汁2022-05-09 16:28:10
坚决玩!离搬入还有三个月,让他们证明三个月找不到替补人!
jjj72022-05-09 16:29:01
没有生效的合同
Girlsmom922022-05-09 16:29:11
我就想知道,from legal point, is this a binding contract or not?
古来万事2022-05-09 16:31:07
我也是这么理解。一旦房东在合同上签字(both parties签字了),合同即刻legally生效。
古来万事2022-05-09 16:34:39
我发现你们两个不是在一个层面上讨论问题。
Girlsmom922022-05-09 16:38:58
房东需要证明他们已经有签字的合约吗?
MrsKwok2022-05-09 16:47:46
这么说吧,房东可以随时签上他们的名字随时传给你女儿..所以说谁先签名谁被动。你女儿如果
Girlsmom922022-05-09 16:47:51
谢谢大家!女儿笫一次租房。以前都住学校的房。
柠檬椰子汁2022-05-09 16:50:27
对,她是良民思维,我是恶棍思维。她说的是如何守规矩,我说的是如何违反规矩不受惩罚。
Girlsmom922022-05-09 16:53:57
就昨天的事。打过电话后。她们也觉得应该email
MrsKwok2022-05-09 16:54:26
哈哈哈,还是职业性质不同,思维模式也不一样。
dld老袁2022-05-09 17:00:19
No, if you offered a lease to landlord, probably there is a
hhtt2022-05-09 17:03:55
那就再改一下?租房改主意关系不大,就是別以后结婚再换人?
hhtt2022-05-09 17:05:12
结婚换人,总比在不幸福的婚姻里强!
老胖妞爱小肥羊2022-05-09 17:09:04
你似乎有点太谨小慎微,这种情况下,我要是landlord 就立马move on 重新找人了,没有精力烦这种没有啥好处的。
Girlsmom922022-05-09 17:21:28
Yeah, i will release them if I have such applicants.
老胖妞爱小肥羊2022-05-09 17:30:39
哈哈哈,玩的就是敌人眼皮下的心跳。
backpack2022-05-09 17:43:21
挺好的一次经验教训。
Girlsmom922022-05-09 19:16:13
上面说错了时间,不是昨天
Girlsmom922022-05-09 19:34:30
Lease 上没有写deadline
MayaLandlord2022-05-09 23:22:56
不用担心,很常见。地主不见钱不会签,不签就没contract。签了就表示收钱了:)
wlwt1232022-05-09 23:46:00
如果哈佛錄了你女兒,寄信後發現有個更好的學生... 不知你會這麼反應?